Civil Rights Groups Demand Court Ban Cops From Stopping Cars

The groups said they want police officers banned from pulling over people for minor offenses.

Cedar Rapids, Iowa - Several civil rights groups want police officers banned from pulling over people for minor offenses because they said that the practice unfairly targets black people.

The groups, ACLU of Iowa, Iowa-Nebraska Conference of the NAACP, League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) of Iowa, and 1,000 Kids for Iowa, filed an amicus curiae brief with the Iowa Supreme Court on Thursday, Nov. 30, according to KGAN.

In the brief, the Linn County Sheriff's Office and the Black Hawk County Sheriff's Office, as well as the Cedar Rapids Police Department and the Waterloo Police Department, were highlighted, according to KCRG.

According to the brief, a 2014 study showed that "people of color" made up 10 percent of drivers, but 19 percent of traffic stops in Iowa City.

However, the author of that study, St. Ambrose University Criminal Justice Professor Chris Barnum, has released newer 2015 numbers which show a downward trend on disproportionate stops.

It's not clear why the civil rights groups ignored the more recent, more accurate numbers.

Barnum also said that census data doesn't actually show if there's any bias in making traffic stops.

"Depending on where the stops are made really determines to a great extent whether there’s disproportionality," Barnum said, according to Press-Citizen. He explained that if police have more patrols in high-crime areas, which have a denser population of people of color, then the numbers will appear more disproportionate.

The civil rights groups also mentioned the November, 2016 traffic stop of Jerime Mitchell in the brief.

Cedar Rapids Police Officer Lucas Jones stopped Mitchell for a burned out license plate light. Mitchell tried to drive away and trapped Officer Jones between an open driver's side door and the truck.

Police said that Officer Lucas feared for his life when he shot Mitchell, who recovered but was paralyzed from the neck down, according to The Gazette. A grand jury investigated the incident at the request of Linn County Attorney Jerry Vander Sanden, and found that the shooting was justified.

Vander Sanden said that evidence was received that indicated Mitchell was on the verge of making a marijuana deal, and that he was profane and belligerent from the start. He also said that Mitchell attacked the officer.

In the brief, the civil rights group recommended that the Iowa Supreme Court come up with a test to determine when racial profiling may be a factor.

They ignored the newer figures because they want to be victims.

Have these people completely lost what little bit of common sense they may have had? If they are so concerned about racial stops then they should concentrate their efforts towards providing education to the groups they claim are being stopped due to racial profiling on how to live so they don't break the laws that are there for their protection as well as other citizens who might be affected by lawless acts, traffic offenses included.

This is one way to reduce the crime rate in black communities.

What if the damn blacks stopped breaking the law? Might work!

Agreed. If you aren’t doing anything wrong they won’t stop you. Boston tried the no police responding routine. They were begging for the cops to come back.

So all a group need do for immunity from cops is become compulsive law breakers? The cops are prejudiced not the people are law breakers. Right...

How about we just discontinue police ops in all minority communities?

Need to find a way to reverse the law suits and make the groups pay for wasting tax payers money on crap like this. This is all for the 10 minutes of fame like Gloria A the super atty doing suites for fame aka Hollywood

Police patrol the areas with a high crime rate whether it be traffic, drugs, burglary, assaults, etc. Why on earth would any department send a bunch of cops to an area where there aren't any problems, that's wasting resources. This whole attitude of a race being picked on is asinine. Look........lets put white cops in white areas, Asian in Asian communities, Black in black communities. Problem solved.......... I'm so sick of the problem children of this country throwing temper tantrums and getting their way. Do the right thing and you wont be in trouble. Get a job, go to work and that will keep you out of trouble, that applies to EVERYONE. Police your own family and hold them responsible and respectful. It all begins at home when kids are little. Parents, teach your children respect. It's your responsibility.

This would be very similar to the rational being used in Oregon to say there are no longer any known gang members living in the State of Oregon. Why, the courts ordered law enforcement to destroy all the records of known gang members. That certainly cleaned up the gang problem.

Conversations